Epson Ecotank Vs HP Smart Tank

You're comparing the Epson EcoTank and HP Smart Tank, each offering unique advantages. If you're budget-conscious, the HP Smart Tank, priced at $249, might appeal to you more than the Epson EcoTank at $699. However, the Epson stands out in ink efficiency and versatility, supporting a wider range of media sizes and types, including borderless prints up to 47.2 inches. It also excels in print quality with a six-color system, ensuring superior color accuracy and sharpness. Both models offer robust connectivity options, including Wi-Fi, but HP includes Bluetooth functionality. Exploring further will illuminate which printer aligns better with your specific needs.

Price Comparison

When comparing the Epson EcoTank Photo ET-8500 and the HP Smart Tank 51001, you'll find that the HP Smart Tank 51001 is much more budget-friendly at $249, compared to the Epson's higher price tag of $699. This significant difference in price makes the HP Smart Tank an attractive option if you're looking to minimize upfront costs.

However, it's crucial to contemplate what each model offers beyond the price. The Epson EcoTank ET-8500 supports borderless printing, a feature that's particularly absent in the HP Smart Tank 51001. This capability is especially valuable if you're interested in producing professional-looking photos and creative projects without the limitations of standard margins.

In making your decision, weigh the importance of borderless printing against the initial savings offered by the HP Smart Tank. The EcoTank's higher cost might be justified by its enhanced features, depending on your specific printing needs. Always ponder how the printer's capabilities align with what you most frequently print to ensure you're getting the best value for your investment. This detailed comparison should help guide your choice between these two competing models.

Ink Efficiency

Considering ink efficiency, the Epson EcoTank Photo ET-8500 offers substantial savings and environmental benefits with its high-yield bottles compared to traditional ink cartridges. Each replacement set of these bottles is equivalent to about 100 individual cartridges, which translates into less waste and more cost-effective printing for you. You'll find this especially beneficial if you're frequently printing high volumes or full-color documents.

On the other hand, the HP Smart Tank 5100, while also using high-yield ink bottles, doesn't support borderless printing. This limitation might affect your choices if your needs include creating prints without margins, such as photos or certain types of marketing materials. Despite this, the HP Smart Tank 5100 still presents a compelling case for ink efficiency, offering significant savings over conventional cartridge-based printers.

Both models promote lower ongoing costs through their refillable systems, but the Epson EcoTank Photo ET-8500 edges out with its broader media handling versatility, allowing you to print not just on standard papers, but also on card stock, CDs, DVDs, and thicker media. This versatility, combined with ink efficiency, makes the Epson a more adaptable choice for varied printing needs.

Media Handling Capabilities

When you compare the media handling capabilities of the Epson EcoTank and HP Smart Tank, you'll find notable differences in their versatility and performance.

The Epson EcoTank, such as the ET-8500, supports a wider range of paper sizes and media types, including borderless prints on card stock and even CDs/DVDs.

In contrast, the HP Smart Tank, like the 5101, doesn't offer borderless printing, which may limit its utility for more creative or expansive projects.

Paper Size Options

Epson EcoTank and HP Smart Tank printers both offer extensive media handling capabilities, accommodating a variety of paper sizes such as letter, legal, and envelopes. You'll find that both printer lines enhance your printing options with versatile capabilities, including borderless printing on selected paper sizes.

However, there's a notable difference in their handling of larger formats. Epson EcoTank can manage media up to 8.5 x 47.2 inches, perfect for creating impressive banners or panoramic photos. In contrast, HP Smart Tank's maximum media size reaches up to 8.5 x 14 inches, focusing more on typical document sizes like legal papers.

This distinction might influence your choice depending on your specific printing needs for larger or more diverse projects.

Supported Media Types

When evaluating the media handling capabilities of both Epson EcoTank and HP Smart Tank printers, it's important to highlight that while Epson supports borderless printing on a diverse range of media types, HP Smart Tank models generally don't offer this feature.

You'll find that Epson EcoTank, particularly models like the Photo ET-8500, excels in handling various materials from card stock to CDs and DVDs, and even media up to 1.3 mm thick. This versatility is ideal for your creative projects, allowing you to produce lab-quality photos with vibrant colors and sharp text.

In contrast, HP Smart Tank printers, including the Smart Tank 5101, focus on standard media handling without the capabilities for borderless outputs on specialized media.

Print Quality Assessment

When evaluating the print quality of Epson EcoTank and HP Smart Tank, you'll want to take into account several key aspects.

First, analyze how accurately each printer reproduces colors, noting that Epson uses a six-color ink system which may impact its performance.

Next, examine the sharpness of text and the resolution of images, important for both document clarity and photo detail.

Color Accuracy Comparison

If you're seeking superior color accuracy in your prints, you might find that Epson EcoTank printers outperform HP Smart Tank models, particularly in photo quality. The Epson EcoTank series boasts a wider color gamut, which is essential for reproducing vibrant and true-to-life hues. This advantage makes EcoTanks more suitable for photo printing where color fidelity is paramount.

In comparison, while HP Smart Tank printers excel in text clarity, they mightn't match the Epson in managing complex color profiles. If your priority is achieving the most accurate color representation, especially in high-quality photo outputs, the EcoTank vs Smart Tank debate leans towards Epson for their enhanced color capabilities.

Text Sharpness Evaluation

Evaluating the text sharpness of Epson EcoTank and HP Smart Tank printers reveals that Epson generally provides sharper text documents, setting a high standard in print quality for detailed work.

Here's a breakdown of the comparison:

  1. Epson EcoTank utilizes advanced print head technology which greatly enhances text sharpness, making it ideal for high-precision tasks.
  2. HP Smart Tank, while offering good document quality, falls slightly behind in achieving the crisp text produced by Epson.
  3. In tasks where document clarity is paramount, users tend to prefer Epson EcoTank for its consistent performance.
  4. Both brands aim to deliver quality, but in a head-to-head comparison, Epson EcoTank generally leads in text sharpness, thanks to its superior print head technology.

Image Resolution Analysis

Let's explore the image resolution capabilities of the Epson EcoTank ET-4850 and the HP Smart Tank Plus 651 to determine which printer offers superior print quality.

The Epson EcoTank ET-4850, with its 1200 x 4800 dpi resolution, excels in producing vibrant colors and sharp text. It can also print a 4×6 photo in just 15 seconds, highlighting its photo printing efficiency.

On the other hand, the HP Smart Tank Plus 651 features a 4800 x 1200 dpi resolution and is known for its slightly better color accuracy in photo outputs. Both printers provide excellent quality for both text and graphics, making the choice between them more about specific needs in print resolution, color fidelity, and printing speed.

Connectivity Options

When comparing connectivity options, Epson EcoTank printers typically include Ethernet and Wi-Fi, while HP Smart Tank models often add Bluetooth, providing you diverse ways to connect and print. Both brands aim to offer all-encompassing solutions that cater to modern printing needs, making it easier for you to choose based on your specific requirements.

Here's a closer look at the connectivity features:

  1. Ethernet Support: Both Epson EcoTank and HP Smart Tank printers include Ethernet ports, guaranteeing you can integrate these printers into a wired network for stable connections and faster data transfer rates.
  2. Wi-Fi Capability: Standard on both models, Wi-Fi connectivity allows for convenient wireless printing from laptops, smartphones, and tablets using network connections. This is ideal if you prefer minimal wires.
  3. Bluetooth Functionality: Exclusive to HP Smart Tank, Bluetooth enhances accessibility, enabling direct printing from devices without needing a Wi-Fi network. This is particularly handy for quick prints from smartphones.
  4. Wi-Fi Direct: HP also offers Wi-Fi Direct, allowing devices to connect directly to the printer without an intermediary network, boosting the ease of setting up and printing immediately.

These connectivity options ensure that both Epson EcoTank and HP Smart Tank printers are versatile choices for varied printing needs.

Additional Features

Beyond connectivity, you'll find that both Epson EcoTank and HP Smart Tank printers offer distinctive additional features tailored to enhance your printing experience. While both support mobile printing, their approaches to connectivity and performance vary, providing unique benefits depending on your needs.

Epson EcoTank models boast Ethernet connectivity, enhancing network stability, which is a plus if you're in a setup where Wi-Fi is unreliable. Additionally, these printers shine in color accuracy and photo quality, making them ideal if your work involves a lot of visual presentations or photo prints.

On the other hand, HP Smart Tank printers include Bluetooth connectivity, a feature that simplifies direct printing from mobile devices without relying on a Wi-Fi network. They also excel in printing speed for black documents, which can be essential if you often have high volumes of text-heavy documents. However, where HP leads in text clarity and speed, it trades off slightly in input paper capacity compared to the EcoTank, which might be a consideration if you're looking to handle large print jobs without frequent reloads.

Both options offer robust features for varied printing needs, emphasizing either speed and text sharpness or color vibrancy and network flexibility.


In comparing Epson EcoTank and HP Smart Tank, you'll find both offer cost-effective ink solutions and diverse media handling. While EcoTank generally leads in ink efficiency, Smart Tank excels in print quality, especially for color and photo printing.

Both feature robust connectivity options, though HP's interface might be more user-friendly. Each has unique additional features; your choice depends on whether you prioritize long-term savings with Epson or enhanced output quality and ease of use with HP.